Governors’ Socioeconomic Issues Committee

The Socioeconomic Issues Committee (SEIC) of the American College of Surgeons (ACS) Board of Governors (B/G) had another busy year. The SEIC has become the largest Governors’ committee, which reflects the broad expanse of socioeconomic factors that affect virtually every aspect of daily surgical practice. Interactions among members at the committee’s annual meeting at the Clinical Congress, and through multiple conference calls throughout the year, clearly reflect the numerous socioeconomic issues that affect the delivery of surgical care in the U.S. and throughout the world.

Humanitarianism and volunteerism

As has been recent practice, the SEIC again had the privilege of reviewing nominations for the ACS/Pfizer Surgical Volunteerism Awards and Surgical Humanitarian Award. The increasing number of candidates for these awards demonstrates the fact that many Fellows are committed to the principles of Operation Giving Back. Their donations of time, talent, and financial support enable programs that bring surgical care and training to patients and health care professionals throughout the world as well as underserved areas of the U.S. The accomplishments of those whom the SEIC selected were described in the September 2012 issue of the Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons;* however, virtually all of the nominees deserve acclaim for their impressive records of selfless dedication to serving where help is needed most.

The inclusion of Robin T. Petroze, MD, a general surgical resident at the University of Virginia, Charlottesville, among the recipients of the 2012 awardees was particularly noteworthy. Dr. Petroze’s work in helping to develop a trauma system in Rwanda demonstrates how residents now have real opportunities to dedicate some of their training time to participation in humanitarian programs and receive appropriate credit from the Accreditation Council on Graduate Medical Education.

Changing practice paradigm

On the domestic front, the SEIC produced a white paper described in last year’s report, which was published in the October 2012 issue of the Bulletin. Titled Surgical Care and Career Opportunities in a Changing Practice Paradigm, the paper is designed to provide insights and information to the surgeon who is facing a change in practice paradigm, either voluntarily or as the result of the continued amalgamation of clinical care into large, integrated health care delivery systems. Recognizing that these changes in practice affect both the mature surgeon and the finishing trainee, the paper is intended to complement the guidelines regarding hospital employment recently published in the ACS booklet titled Surgeons As Institutional Employees: A Strategic Look at the Dimensions of Surgeons As Employees of Hospitals. Developed by the ACS Division of Advocacy and Health Policy, the brochure was disseminated with the February 2013 issue of the Bulletin.

Surgical Care and Career Opportunities in a Changing Practice Paradigm is currently under peer review for publication in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons and includes a six-part discussion of critical socioeconomic factors that affect many of the processes described in Surgeons As Institutional Employees. The white paper begins with an overview of the characteristics of the changing health care environment, including the impact of health care reform legislation and emerging models of funding for clinical care. The next four sections are designed to assist the surgeon in assessing a prospective employer or partner. These portions of the document focus on identifying critical characteristics that ensure the type of practice or health care organization under consideration will offer professional and personal satisfaction and will allow the surgeon to remain an effective and meaningful advocate for the surgical patient and for optimal quality of care.

The final section of the document addresses the new “product” of surgical practice. In the evolving systems of shared risk and shared reward, surgeons and all acute care providers will find that productivity will be measured based on quality of care provided rather than simply volume of relative value units produced and reported. This new era will require that acute care professionals work with primary care providers to ensure that a population’s chronic diseases are effectively managed so that when acute events do occur, patients are optimally prepared to sustain the acute insult with least potential for deterioration of related or unrelated chronic comorbidities. The acute care provider—among whom the surgical specialist is often most prominent—must, in turn, earn the trust of the primary care practitioner by ensuring that patients requiring surgical intervention receive the highest quality of care.

The mandate is clear: now more than ever surgeons must advocate for optimal quality across the continuum of patient care, define quality in objective terms, and actively lead efforts to evaluate the provision of care to ensure that quality is both optimal and continuously improved. Recognizing that the new paradigm demands a surgical “product” that is as focused on quality assurance as it is on number of surgical interventions, the SEIC offers in this final section a first glimpse at the pathway to the future. Surgeons who remain disengaged from quality improvement efforts will become technical commodities in the professional services cost center of massive integrated health care delivery systems. Those who understand and embrace the full commitment to optimal surgical care will remain the patient’s most important advocate and will guide, if not lead, these emerging systems of care.

Future directions

The evolving redesign of the B/G will provide current and future Governors with even greater opportunities to focus their talents and time on College activities that will enhance focus and productivity. In so doing, the Governors will become even more effective in their role as the voice and agents of the Fellows.

In light of the many broad issues discussed previously and the ever-changing socioeconomic environment in which Fellows must practice effectively, the committee’s objectives will be redefined to reflect the broad nature of its focus and accomplishments over the past five years. The SEIC will become the Health Policy and Advocacy Workgroup, which resides under the Advocacy pillar of the redesigned B/G—same people, same mission, yet working with more efficiency to continue the same commitment to excellence for surgical care of all of our patients.

Members of the Governors’ Socioeconomic Issues Committee

Joseph J. Tepas III, MD, FACS, Chair

David B. Adams, MD, FACS

David Arbutina, MD, FACS

Linda M. Barney, MD, FACS

Kevin Eugene Behrns, MD, FACS

Michael O. Bernstein, MD, FACS

Bruce J. Brener, MD, FACS

Dale Buchbinder, MD, FACS

Richard J. Buckley, Jr., MD, FACS

Lynn Randolph Buckner, MD, FACS

David Felix Canal, MD, FACS

David W. Cloyd, MD, FACS

Walter C. Dandridge, Jr., MD

Anthony D. Dippolito, MD, MBA, FACS

Mary E. Fallat, MD, FACS

Tyler G. Hughes, MD, FACS

James L. Kessler, MD, FACS

Deborah Susan Loeff, MD, FACS

Nipun B. Merchant, MD, FACS

Mark William Moritz, MD, FACS

Susan L. Orloff, MD, FACS

James Aloysius Reilly, Jr., MD, FACS

Chad A. Rubin, MD, FACS

Robert C. Shamberger, MD, FACS

Mika N. Sinanan, MD, PhD, FACS

Howard Lawrence Sussman, MD, FACS

Nicholas Blair Vedder, MD, FACS

Matthew J. Wall, Jr., MD, FACS

Lewis Wetstein, MD, FACS

Liaison Members

Adnan Ali Alseidi, MD, FACS

James Clinton Denneny III, MD, FACS

Elan R. Witkowski, MD


Robert R. Bahnson, MD, FACS

Kathleen M. Casey, MD, FACS

Charles D. Mabry, MD, FACS

John G. Meara, MD, FACS

Andrew L. Warshaw, MD, FACS


John Chingswei Chen, MD, FACS


Jamie Kazay, ACS Division of Member Services

*Casey K, Kodera A. Fellows honored for volunteerism. Bull Am Coll Surg. 2012;97(9):74-76.

Vickers, SM. Governors’ Committee on Socioeconomic Issues. Bull Am Coll Surg. 2012;97(10):51-56.

Tagged as: , , , ,


Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons
633 N. Saint Clair St.
Chicago, IL 60611


Download the Bulletin App

Apple Store
Get it on Google Play
Amazon store